Decking Decisions: Choosing the Right Material for Your Outdoor Space

Sam Tidwell, CEO, Good Morning Remodel

Building a deck is an exciting way to expand your living space and enhance your backyard’s functionality and charm. But the material you choose plays a big role in how your deck will look, how long it will last, and how much maintenance it will require. At Good Morning Remodel, we work with a variety of decking materials—but pressure-treated wood and composite decking are by far the most common choices for our clients.

In this post, we’ll walk you through the most popular decking materials on the market, highlight the strengths and weaknesses of each, and help you feel confident in choosing the one that suits your lifestyle and budget best.

Pressure-Treated Wood

A budget-friendly classic with natural charm

Pressure-treated lumber is the most commonly used decking material in the U.S.—and for good reason. It offers the warmth and beauty of real wood at a relatively low price point. This lumber is infused with preservatives that help it resist rot, mold, and insect damage, making it a practical choice for a wide range of environments.

Why homeowners choose it:

  • Affordability: Significantly less expensive than composite or hardwood decking

  • Customizable appearance: Can be painted, stained, or sealed to suit your style

  • Availability: Readily accessible in many sizes and styles

What to keep in mind:

  • Requires sealing or staining every 1–2 years

  • May warp, crack, or splinter over time

  • Shorter lifespan compared to other materials (typically 10–15 years)

Composite Decking

Low-maintenance and long-lasting with a clean, finished look

Composite decking is a favorite among homeowners who want a modern, uniform appearance and long-term performance. Made from a blend of recycled wood fibers and plastic, these boards are engineered to stand up to the elements with minimal upkeep.

Why homeowners choose it:

  • Low maintenance: No need to paint or seal—just an occasional rinse

  • Durability: Won’t rot, splinter, or fade like traditional wood

  • Design options: Wide selection of colors, grain patterns, and board widths

What to keep in mind:

  • Higher initial cost compared to wood

  • Some boards may retain heat in full sun

  • Proper installation is key for ventilation and drainage

Alternative Decking Options with Unique Benefits

Cedar and Redwood

Naturally beautiful softwoods with rich color and character

These softwoods are prized for their natural resistance to decay and insects, as well as their warm tones and attractive grain. Cedar and redwood bring an upscale feel to traditional wood decking.

Pros

Naturally resistant to rot and bugs

Visually appealing with a rich, organic look

Stays cooler than composites on hot days

Cons

More expensive than pressure-treated wood

Requires sealing or oiling to prevent fading

Softer surface is more vulnerable to wear

Best fit for:
Those seeking a natural wood deck with a high-end appearance and are prepared for regular care.

PVC (Plastic) Decking

Moisture-resistant and ultra-low maintenance

PVC is an all-plastic alternative that’s perfect for wet or coastal climates. It resists moisture and mold with ease and won’t absorb water like wood-based materials can.

Pros

100% moisture- and rot-resistant

Lightweight and durable

Available in various finishes, including wood-look textures

Cons

May look less natural

Can be more slippery and hot underfoot

Typically a premium price point

Best fit for:
Homeowners in wet, humid climates who want the lowest-maintenance option available.

Aluminum Decking

Strong, long-lasting, and highly resistant to the elements

Aluminum decking isn’t commonly used for residential decks, but it’s a powerhouse when it comes to strength, weather resistance, and longevity.

Pros

Will not rot, rust, warp, or crack

Fire-resistant and extremely durable

Reflects heat and stays cooler in direct sun

Cons

Expensive compared to most materials

More industrial or modern look

Limited availability in some regions

Best fit for:
Specialized or modern applications where long-term performance is key.

Don’t Forget the Details: Railings, Fascia, and More

While decking boards are the most visible part of your structure, they’re not the only materials you’ll need to consider. A complete deck includes several other components that influence appearance, safety, and longevity:

  • Railings: Available in wood, composite, metal, or cable. Your choice can dramatically affect the overall style of your deck and may be required by code, depending on height.

  • Fascia boards: These trim the edges of your deck, giving it a finished look and helping protect the frame.

  • Fasteners: Hidden fasteners, face screws, or clips can change both the visual finish and maintenance requirements.

  • Skirting or underdecking: Optional but popular for hiding structural elements or adding storage below the deck.

Choosing the right combination of these materials can enhance your deck’s look and function while complementing your home’s style.

Ready to Build Your Perfect Deck?

Whether you want the traditional warmth of pressure-treated wood or the low-maintenance ease of composite, the best deck material for you will depend on your lifestyle, your home’s aesthetics, and how much upkeep you’re willing to take on.

At Good Morning Remodel, we’re here to help you navigate every step—from choosing the right material to delivering a finished deck that feels like a true extension of your home.

Let’s build something great together.

Prefer a quick summary? Check out our design document titled Choosing the Right Decking Material for a clear, at-a-glance comparison of the most popular options.